Transit Smart Card fare payment has ability to significantly reduce time buses spend waiting at bus stops for passengers to board.

Analysis of the impact of smart card fare payments on transit bus dwell time in Los Angeles

Los Angeles; California; United States

Summary Information

This report analyzes the impact of smart card fare payments on transit bus dwell time. Dwell time is the amount of time transit vehicles spend at stops while processing boarding passengers. Shorter dwell times help improve travel speeds and reduce headways, which encourages patronage. Although it is just one of the many aspects that determine the length of dwell times, electronic fare payment, such as Los Angeles Metro’s Transit Access Pass (TAP), is thought to help decrease that amount of time. A transit research team examined the effect of TAP card usage on bus dwell times by analyzing data automatically generated from on-board transit systems.


A regression model of dwell time by fare payment type was estimated. For the model, Metro provided Universal Farebox System (UFS) and Automatic Passenger Counter (APC) data from March 3 to March 16, 2014. Because prior work suggests that limited-stop services have different dwell times than local services, two contrasting Metro bus lines were selected for analysis: a limited-service, low ridership neighborhood route (Local Route 120) and a high volume, high frequency rapid route (Rapid Route 720).

After throwing out outliers, the sample size consisted of 540,407 fare payment records and 99,453 dwell time records across 342 operators and 187 vehicles. Linear regressions analysis was used to statistically control other factors known to influence dwell times – including number of passengers boarding and alighting, wheelchairs, bicycles, bus type and configuration, and service (local, express, etc.).

  • Statistically significant coefficients show that smart card payments contribute roughly two seconds per person to dwell time, while cash or other media contribute about four seconds. If 100,000 current customers (or about 20 percent of current non-TAP paying customers) were to switch to TAP cards, Metro buses would spend about 56 fewer hours per day waiting at bus stops.
  • The study also found that the effect of TAP card usage on dwell times appears to erode appreciably in crowded conditions, meaning there are likely more cost-effective ways to reduce dwell times – such as all-door boarding at high-volume stops and stations.

Benefit Comments

No comments posted to date

Comment on this Benefit

To comment on this summary, fill in the information below and click on submit. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field. Your name and email address, if provided, will not be posted, but are to contact you, if needed to clarify your comments.


Making Headways: An Analysis of Smart Cards and Bus Dwell Time in Los Angeles

Author: Daniel B. Shockley, Julia Salinas, Brian D. Taylor

Published By: Transportation Research Board

Source Date: 08/01/2015



Average User Rating

0 ( ratings)

Rate this Benefit

(click stars to rate)

Goal Areas


Typical Deployment Locations

Metropolitan Areas


smart cards, electronic fare payment, SmartCard, smart card, SmartCards

Benefit ID: 2016-01100